FICCI Frames 2012 Speech


Hi All,

Hope everyone is well. It’s been six hectic months since the release of  Revolution 2020, including a lot of travel around the country. I am thankful to all of you for the wonderful response. 

Today I spoke at the FICCI Frames 2012, an entertainment industry conference organized every year in Mumbai. I am glad they gave writers a chance to speak there. 

My speech there was somewhat industry specific, but it was themed on about something close to me – change. Hence, thought I’d post it here.

—————————————-

FICCI Frames 2012 Keynote Address

Chetan Bhagat

——————————————

First of all I’d like to thank the FICCI frames organizers for giving me and other writers a chance to talk in a conference on the entertainment and film industry.

Writers are not supposed to talk. Traditionally, writers in the film industry work silently, even though they pretty much decide every word that is spoken on screen. Every film tells a story. Without a story, you cannot make a film. You can replace actors with animations, you can skip the music, you may not erect huge sets – but you must have a story. For something so critical, it is befuddling why the role of writers here has been less than many other departments.

Of course, it is a star driven industry. I don’t believe for a second when people say that the ‘story is the star’ in the movie, even as a writer. No, I am saying that stars are important, directors are important, marketing is important, the producer is important – but the story and screenplay, and thus the creator of the story are important people too. I am no activist, but more as someone who likes to analyze things I have tried to understand the problem. Why don’t writers get visibility, compensation and the same attention as say – music directors, who are known and rightly so. But why not also writers?

I see two main reasons for the same.

One, the single biggest reason, is the audience pardoning bad stories. Our Indian audiences love our films. They are crazy about Bollywood and their stars. And in this allure, they pardon a lot of sins. This isn’t very different from how Indians looked at their politicians. Charisma was everything. Of course, a certain minimum was expected, but that was quite a low standard. As long as the stars looked good, could create a few laughs or thrills, the songs and dance were nice to listen to and watch – people would give a thumbs up to a movie. In fact, the Bollywood story became nothing to write home about – it was not meant to touch people, just keep them hooked or engaged for the duration of the movie. The movie ends, and as train passengers, the audience would simply say goodbye and leave the characters behind.

‘Fully filmy story man,’ is how people describe our films. Every now and then, a movie would come that would touch the core of our being. Something that made us think and feel – even after the end credits rolled. We enjoyed that experience, but that was so rare that it couldn’t be expected in every movie. ‘Keep your brains at home’, ‘It’s a Hindi movie, what else do you expect?’, ‘just time pass’ are all phrases we have heard. When the audience cared about the heroine’s figure and the hero’s punch more than the narrative, the makers cared little about writers. A story and screenwriter were engaged like a bare minimum and thus few shined in the department.

The second reason is a unique aspect of Indian culture, which is the exploitation and abuse of power, by those who can. It is considered acceptable in our value system that the more powerful will get a bigger share, irrespective of whether they deserve it or not. From a traffic cop to a minister, we have seen examples of people exploiting their position to gain an unfair advantage. So if a writer deserved a slice of the pizza, but the producer distributed it, the writer had to do with scraps. “This is how it happens in Bollywood,’ was drilled down people’s throats.  Writers became used to less money. However, the few times their work was noted, producers and directors pounced on another thing – credit. Whatever was good in the story, the producers and directors thumped their chests and took credit for it. Why? Because they could. They had power and thus they did it. In the end, the film writer could never make a brand for himself,. He had noone to appeal to and had no choice but to lump it.

Hence, a manifestation of some typically Indian habits, audience indifference and power exploitation, found its way in Bollywood, and hurt the writers.

But we know all this.

 The question is how do we change it. How do we change audience preferences, and the power order established over generations. Well, I have always believed, people change when they want to change. People change when they believe change will do them some good, make them a better person or give them a better life.  Well, good stories do enrich our lives. Stories that touch us do make us feel happy and alive. And slowly, the audience is realizing this.

The audience today is cluttered with content. 200 TV channels, noisy social networks, the Internet, smartphones, print media, radio – everyone is being bombarded in every direction by content. It is natural that people will develop a certain numbness to it. A fashionable actress was a big draw earlier, but if I see pictures of ten of them in a day, it is difficult to be so excited about it. More than anything, so much content means the content isn’t created with much thought. Recycling, clichés, formulas are being tried everywhere – from fashion weeks to reality TVs to even movies. The audience is in stupor. The easy ways to catch attention – a striking visual, a catchy beat – doesn’t seem to work as well. People now want more. They want entertainers to touch their core – one of the few things that can touch your core is a good story.  Films that have worked – Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara, Dirty Picture, and currently Kahani show that the audience likes content too.  Yes they were star vehicles, but content is inching ahead.  LSD, Shor in the city, Stanley ka Dabba are some recent pure content successes. The day is not far where people won’t pay for movies without content. Just as more and more Indians are asking for more accountable politicians, similarly, we are going to see a demand for content. This means writers will have to be brought on the boardroom table.

The second part, changing the power equation is a little harder. Of course, as a few writers deliver consistent hits, their power will rise. Then they too can demand their fair share. This is the argument many would make. However, this is not how a fair community is organized. Whether a writer is powerful or not, he or she should get his or her due. In fact, everyone in the unit should. A set of values, ethics has to come to our film industry. If it doesn’t, a lot of talent will shy away. Only established guys and their protégés will function, and while they may grow – the industry as a whole will grow much slower than it could in a true and fair meritocracy. In Hollywood, they faced this same problem in the 1950s, issue of credit – used to cause a lot of concern there. Soon, norms were set. For example, they would stipulate, credit number 4 will belong to the writer, in the same font and size as that of the director. It isn’t up to the whim of the producer. The author of the story cannot be changed – it is the fundamental copyright law. You can buy a painting. You cannot say you painted it.  The producer or director cannot put their name on a story they haven’t written, even if they have paid for it. Such norms have helped reduce conflict in Hollywood, ensured fair play and brought them a whole bunch of content.

Literature and Bollywood complement each other. Literature can use the fame provided by Bollywood. Bollywood can use the content created by Literature. The audience is starting to demand it. Bollywood needs to adapt it to grow to its potential – not just to make money – but to be a great industry where there is both commercial and creative growth.

I hope, the changes I talk about come soon, for they have to come eventually anyway. Let us all in our capacity, act as catalysts and support this change, rather than resist or thwart it.

For life and films should not be just measured in how much money they made, but how many people they touched. It isn’t about money, it is about being great. And trust me, writers will help you get there.

Thank you.

 

 


21 Comments

Leave a Comment

  1. Amit Singh says:

    Yes Chetan, finally the change is coming in Bollywood. thanks to young and new directors like Tigmanshu Dhulia, Anurag Khashyap, Farahan Akhtar, Zoya Akhtar and many more who are really giving importance to credit.
    And Yes Audience like us ( earning youth ) now days are really looking for good scripted movies.
    Now, I look forward for Irrfan Khan movies rather than any other Khan’s movies.

  2. very well said….film industries are doing their work in all the areas script writing,marketing,choreography,screen play
    for producing money..but it is ultimate the audience who will decide,to which they give the importance.

  3. vinita kumari says:

    You have said the t true thing. We remember the movie for a long time if there is a good story.People should also realize this.You have kept the reality very nicely.

  4. Raj says:

    Great commentary on writing and its recognition. Here are a couple of other observations to chew on. I think that the recognition for the film’s story is almost completely along age-lines. Without hard numbers to back up my theory, I am guessing that Kahaani appealed to young audiences, who have been exposed to the twist of the movie, Sixth Sense or the tales of Jeffrey Archer. Older audiences were not so thrilled. 3 idiots – on the other hand, with its lovable characters, catchy songs, the perennially favorite topic of competitive Indian colleges and a satisfying finish was different yet had mass appeal and every age group loved it. I would love to be able to get the stats. to validate/negate my theory.

  5. viral says:

    yes chetan jee u r right. and not only in bollywood but in most of the sectors, real men underestimated.

  6. shilpa yadava says:

    flims should touch and prick our souls .nowdays we like some extent of rawness in characters and in storylines.

  7. mayur baldha says:

    Yes,agree to u..

    As the stars,directors & all went beyond their root thing of acting,

    think beyond “MONEY”.

  8. VARUN ARORA says:

    exactly, that is the reason bollywood movies never won foreign movie awards
    here directors main focus was on item song,looks that’s it. no story
    their main emphasis on overacting,
    i dont know how movies like om shanti om,ra.one got succed we all know that nothin in them complete rubbish
    i guess the problem is that in bollywood
    WE HAVE STAR,no ACTOr for them appearence matter for eg shahid kapoor crowd love him bcoz he is sexy,dance well enough who cares about acting
    but ironically in same bollywood we had actor like IRFAAN KHAN,AAMIR KHAN NOT GOOD DANCER,NO HEIGHT BUT BRILLANT ACTOR
    HERE STORY MOVE AROUND ACTORS
    NOT ACTOR WORKS ACCORDING STORY
    IT IS MY REQUEST TO FILM DIRECTORS,PRODUCERS,STARS GIVE IDENTIFICATION TO WRITERS AND ACTOR
    and yes bring some honesty in awards ceremony
    THANKYOU

  9. VARUN says:

    For those who dont have better options, I don’t stop them from drinking. I think Swami ramdev also wont. But here is a funny video about it http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kH-cdAPfz4&list=UU_HDxzp6ScExhWkuakvGGYw&feature=plcp

  10. Raji Subramanian says:

    Many of the younger generation like my son think that they want to become a writer like you. He is 13 years old and tells CHetan never wanted to become an IITian .

    They also think they can become writer by browsing in the net

    I want you to clarify the reputation yOu got has a background of being an iiitian and IIM at least to to the extent of 10%

  11. Bhavna Chhabria says:

    Hi i am big fan of your writing ,once i complete reading your book i wait other one. i have read all your books.please tell me when is your new book coming .

    Thanking you
    Bhavna

  12. anurag chanderi says:

    I teach english language and literature , usually find that todays students are really very much impressed by ur dynamic power of thoughs , thanq very much dear sir

  13. Dilip says:

    I absolutely have to agree.

    For the record, I watch movies for their story and not for the stars. I don’t give a damn who the actor is, who the director is, who has an item number in a movie. I care about the story. I care about what is being said, and how it is being said. I pay attention to how a complicated storyline is simplified and presented in around 2 hours.

    Good acting, good direction, camera work, screen play, music – they are all appreciated AFTER watching the movie. But a good story is what drives me to go watch the movie in the first place.

    This means I watch only 2 or 3 Hindi movies a year- I’d rather watch a Hollywood movie with a good story instead of wasting time and money on a bland Hindi movie.

    To all the people in the film industry- Chetan Bhagath is right. People like me exist. We respect our writers. We are growing in numbers. But thats not your biggest problem- your biggest problem is that we are the ones generating content on the internet. We write reviews for your dvds on amazon, we blog and tweet about your movies, and everyone recycles our work on the internet. Soon, the mainstream news will pay attention to the blogosphere in India. At that point, our opinions will matter more than your marketing campaigns.

    Alright, now let me go back to my evil plan that will let me take over the world!

  14. VINNY JUNEJA says:

    I was into writing since my childhood but thanx to U i want to do it more and more and for that i have read tons of novels.I seriously hope that one day I would have my own FANCAFE and people will write to me (HOPE U KNOW WHAT I MEAN;-))

  15. ChetanBhgat will be next VivekaNanad, He is doing same what Vivekanand did. He need to take first step. He should visit Patanjali peeth at least once.

  16. Anish says:

    As you told most of the odience keep there brain at home while coming for a movie they dont care what the message of the movie,for example we know what rajnikanth do in films its impossibe in reality,and the red color liquid coming out of the body is not blood.but if u watch the film with ‘its all fake.i m intelligent all others who r watching r fools’attitude u cant enjoy the movie.

    but now a days our young educated generation do giv respect to the script,they thinks the actor could hav done “this” in place of “that”

  17. anil kumar says:

    hi,
    happy dipawali to you with family.pl. mail me about your new book.
    —–anil kumar

  18. PARESH CHAUHAN says:

    Namashkar chetanji
    I like your speech
    Sir…..I want to meet you…I am member of (FWA) mumbai since 2002…presently I hve a very big issue with one big producer ….I need your advice…I m quite confused
    PLEASE.

    Paresh chauhan (writer)
    M.09904873121

  19. all the time i used to read smaller content which as
    well clear their motive, and that is also happening with this article which I
    am reading at this time.

Leave a Comment

Facebook Twitter